WEEK 13 FEEDBACK

Well done today.
It was fantastic to see that everyone had taken on board our request to work with the billboard, and it is clear that you all have briefs for the site as well as an idea about what elements constitute a piece of “civic wondrous” architecture. We now need to apply these ideas to the site, and to begin to work them up, in tandem with developing the spatial brief in more detail and completing appropriate site analysis.

5th  year have approximately 3 weeks to make and present a first iteration of their scheme in preparation for an engineer.
We suggest that 4th years follow the same trajectory.
The schemes should be designed before Easter please, so that you have enough time to make iterative and exemplary drawings and models, which you have and are making tests for.

To help we suggest  that you concentrate on the following for next week.
1. Scenario/ timeline drawing.
Create a drawing that creates the “business’” case for your proposal which should be backed up by research data.
Why should your project exist, who actually is going use it, and how does it come about ?

2. Project description in 60/100 words that gives a title to the project, outlines its intention and starts with a question that becomes the topic of further research.
eg. How can the architecture of Schools promote a sense of and support community learning?

3. Update your billboard drawing.
The billboard is an opportunity to design a space and really test the intentions expressed in your visual manifesto. Please be ambitious.
It should also communicate to an audience who are not necessarily architects.
Refer to the last direction on this – on the blog.

4. Proposal drawings and models.
Start to test your ideas on scaled drawings of the site: Plans and sections as appropriate.
You will require another site visit to complete the analysis.
We want to understand how the work to date informs the initial proposals.
This should be clear.

WK 12 FEEDBACK & WORK FOR THE CROSS CRIT

GENERAL FEEDBACK FROM DIANA AND KEVIN
1. There has been a big improvement in graphic and research skills… so keep going.
2. We need to carry on practicing and improving all of the drawings so that each student develops a strong signature “style’ … use the blog references.
3. It’s unclear what many of you learned, specifically from the Bilbao trip. This should be fed very directly into the portfolio (some of this maybe be in the films).
4. We need to start quickly on the OKR research, and most importantly on design.

GENERAL FEEDBACK FROM ELLY AND TOM
1. Although it was interesting to see and hear about the detailed manifestos, this was a good exercise, many drawn conclusions are still too generic.
2. They wanted the conclusions to be more architectural and actually descriptive of what types of architecture/ architectural features you will use to make design proposals on the Old Kent Road.
3. They wanted to see more about what you learned architecturally and spatially in Bilabo – specifically architectural responses with interesting combinations of features.

FOR THE CRIT & PORTFOLIO SUBMISSION
Please include
1. Precedent research x 3, observations & analysis. Clearly laid out and explained in lots of detail.
2. Precedent models. Well photographed (see examples on the website). The best images can make one full page as single images.
3. Bilbao Study Film. (Play a maximum of 3 mins at the crit). Ensure the key elements of the Study are clearly highlight and have prominence in the portfolio.
4. Architectural and Spatial Visual manifesto with a reference key. Some of these need more work please.  This should be a detailed, skilled, complex and stunning piece of work that everyone wants to talk about.
5. Chosen site and any research / analysis / photography of site. Use Google/ Bing if you must. Plan carefully what you need to photograph/ research for the next site visit (end Jan).
6. Focused research & analysis into your chosen area of interest for the design proposal. If you don’t know where to look, ask and we will try to help.
7. Clearly outline what the content of the proposal is using the Billboard. See advice below.

BILLBOARD, A NEW DRAWING FOR CRIT
Original we asked you to create a billboard that advertises the service of the building and not the architecture.
However after the crit, we would like you to try to create a drawing that is more spatial and illustrates what architectural approach that you are taking. This approach should be informed by all of the work you have done to date.

The billboard show  include the following content as a minimum
1. Project Name
2. Date the building will open
3. A diagram/ list of spaces & services the building will provide
4. Location on the Old Kent Road
5. One key space (interior or public space) drawn in perspective that brings together one, some or all of the design qualities identified in the visual manifesto. This drawing should allow us to see what it might be like to inhabit the proposed building.

PLEASE NOTE
The Billboard should be largely visual with limited text. Identify a precedent to help you create it (we can then work with you to help them improve it).
We have attached some good examples, but please also see the image sin the original brief

IMAGES

 

Wk 12 crit 

Crit list, order … We might have to reassign  times if we need a break . Train delayed but we hope to start at 1030.

1030 Andrea

11 Roshni

1130 Leo

12 Nicola

1230 David

1 Claire

130 Chelsea

2 Dan

230 Antigioni

3 Hanah

330 Roberto

4 Seun

430 Tom

5 Erna

730 Carol concert ! 

Week 9 Feedback

Well done on Monday, it was great to see people making progress with their projects.
Some general comments:

1) Make sure you are consistent with your process and that this is evidenced in your drawings e.g. for each precedent you should document your observation (a visual recording), the analysis (diagrams, annotations to describe what you have learnt) and your polemic (theoretical position and rational to help you develop a strong case for the design qualities you are interested in developing in your building). These tasks directly relate to site analysis tasks carried out in practice.

2)  Developing a ‘polemic’ means that you are taking a theoretical position, it defines your attitude towards designing architecture that is ” Civic and Wondrous”. The more you are able to argue and support your case with clarity, the more others (clients, public)  will be willing to believe in the architecture that you want to create. Therefore talk about things in terms of benefits e.g.What is the benefit of preserving historic buildings? What is the benefit of designing architecture that brings the community together? What is the benefit of ornamentation in contemporary architecture? Please make sure that you document your polemical position in your portfolio.  Use theoretical references that help to build your case.

3) Try to avoid creating a Manifesto that just simply repeats elements from your earlier drawings. Each drawing should help your project evolve.  This is your first chance to test your design and spatial ingredients by bringing them all together and creating something new with spatial and material properties. It is a clear ‘vision’ for the type of architecture you might create for the Old Kent Road: design a City, Space or Object.  Link images, examples and ideas together.  Follow the graphical rules of your precedent closely. Where possible use examples that we gave you as part of the brief.

For next week. please bring the following:
– Three graphic precedents for laying out your portfolio sheets
– Visual Manifesto Precedent
– Re-draw your visual manifesto as discussed in the crit
– Three stories/ articles/ statistics about the Old Kent Road and how it is used. These could be historical or contemporary, but they should begin to highlight the problems/ issues that you want to explore when proposing the programme for your buildings.
– Three potential sites that you want to consider exploring along the Old Kent Road with a reason as to why you are interested in them. We will use these with you to help to build a masterplan and individual projects.

Week 10 – 2 x tutorials ( 1 x site, 1 x graphic coommunication)

Week 11 – reading week

Week 12 – Crit with external critics  – work from whole term including your developing brief/ first design for the OKR

References – making a new architecture out of limited components (your 10 manifesto points)

http://www.mcescher.com/gallery/back-in-holland/balcony/

http://www.mcescher.com/gallery/impossible-constructions/

http://www.fleafollyarchitects.com/?border_gallery=projects

http://www.fleafollyarchitects.com/?border_portfolio=grimm-city-book

Week 3/4 crit

Everyone has made good progress with their models, which was great to see. Just a few pieces of advice for you all:

1) Remember the role of studying these precedents is to discover and explore the architectural qualities that you think are civic and wondrous.
This could be light, materiality, scale, function, history and so on.  You will then use these qualities to develop your own design language in your architectural propositions when we return from Bilbao.

2) When creating your models  investigate your precedents analytically  and use your model to communicate your learning. They are not just representations of the existing.
There should be a whole array of research in the background to support your model investigations. Next week please bring all of your research with you so that we can see your process.

3) Bring your investigations to a strong conclusion.  Explain to us clearly what you have discovered, learnt and want to question further.
The more you understand of the qualities you are exploring the more depth you will have in your own design explorations later on.

4) Build you models layer by layer, use the workshop, experiment will all the machines and tools that are available.
Start simply in order to build complexity.  Please make sure that they are built with care and skill
Don’t try to do everything at once otherwise the models become overly abstract or complicated.

The Crit will be next Thursday 22nd starting at 10am.
We will order the crit list to accommodate seminars etc. Please meet at 10am to discuss this.
For this we would like you to complete the 3 pieces of work that you have started that make up the spatial lexicon
1. using your Canterbury example
2. using your precedent study
3. using one example from the London trip
4. Supporting research drawings / diagrams / documentation for all of the above

Week 2

Thank-you for coming to London on Monday.
We hope that you all understood the value and reason for our choice of the route on Monday.
From xl large civic buildings of national importance, through to instrumental neighbourhood buildings (Peckham) and even a temporary example.
The two interiors were more hidden in the city but, no less civic, powerful, pleasurable and welcoming experiences, expressed explicitly through the architecture.
We showed you some more successful examples and some less successful.
We want you to use your analytical judgement to understand what is going on … in each situation

Read the Serpentine review and compare this with your own writing
http://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2015/jun/28/serpentine-pavilion-all-style-no-shelter

To take your spatial lexicon’s forward
You are looking for the set of “ingredients” that make up spaces and building that you have chosen as examples to study.
It is important that you analyse these spaces and buildings carefully and that you begin to break them down into the components/ elements that make up the particular set of civic or surprizing experiences that you recognise.

Physical Qualities
Watch ‘The Social Life of Small Urban Spaces’ by William H. Whyte
https://civicwondrous.wordpress.com/references-2/
This is a great example of how to observe the physical qualities of an existing civic place.
Start simply with components of space, materiality, scale, plane, object, light, sound, opening, movement etc. (physical Qualities)

Use reviews / texts you find online or in the library to help you understand the physical qualities of the space. Demonstrate your understanding of how your chosen architectural examples create their specific qualities. e.g. light or sound qualities. Describe architecturally how that quality of light is achieved etc.

Non- Physical Qualities
To describe the ‘non – physical’ qualities, we need more ‘facts’ than just ‘feelings’ – research the context, collect past, present and future narratives, gather memories, local traditions & rituals and describe the experience of use. In doing so, you will demonstrate that a building or place can embrace a whole array of knowledge, stories, activities and traditions that stretch beyond the physical objects that can be touched.
Represent both physical and no physical layers with care and skill.
Build up the lexicon’s quality in specific layers .

For the week 4 crit
For this we would like you to complete the 3 pieces of work that you have started that make up the spatial lexicon
1. using your Canterbury example
2. using your precedent study
3. using one example from the London trip
As required we will have a crit in Wk 4 – Monday 19th October.

Monday 5th October

As in DS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

London site visit

Get the 9.09 train from Canterbury East

You will be in Victoria at 1051

Buy travel cards for the day/ oyster cards

Take the 52 from bus stop H and get off at the top of Exhibition Road.

Walk to the Serpentine Pavilion Café for 1130/45

The gallery is not open on Mondays.

We will walk past the

  • Royal Albert Hall
  • The College of musicians
  • Visit the V&A (some tutorials) – case study/ drawing and analysis
  • Visit the Natural History museum – case study/ drawing and analysis

2.30pm (ish) Tube from South Kensington to Ely Place (Holborn/ Chancery lane)

http://www.stetheldreda.com/ – case study/ drawing and analysis

http://www.yeoldemitreholborn.co.uk/

 

Walk to snow hill stop (4 mins)

4pm (ish)  Bus 63 to Peckham Library via the Old Kent Road (some tutorials)

Might get off and walk along the Old Surrey Canal through Burgess Park to the library

Visit Peckham Library is open until 8pm – case study/ drawing and analysis

NB Franks/ Nines/ Bussey rooftop bar are not open on a Monday – but worth consideration/ study under “Civic Wondrous”

http://www.busseyrooftopbar.com/

http://frankscafe.org.uk/

18.38/ 7.55pm/ 8.55pm/ 9.55pm

Trains back to Canterbury east via Bromley South

 

Please bring umbrellas and good walking shoes.

Please read the risk assessment ( below) and make a note of my number.

Bring sketchbooks in which you can draw as you travel.

Be prepared to work during the day.

Buy travel cards for the day/ oyster cards.

Sketchbooks are for sketching only …. no ‘shopping’ or ‘to do’ lists.

Invest in a concertina one if you can, or one for your pocket.

Bring cameras.

Bring 3/5 pictures of each of your models (requirements of brief 2).

 

made in toyoko

 

 

 

 

 

 

MArch_Unit5_ARxxx_Design_London_Risk_Assessement_2015.rev00